‘Managerial’ turn undermines the ‘public’ in public administration
In recent years, managerialism has gained ground in public administration, and the field has increasingly come to emphasize management at the expense of its public purpose. Image generated by AI
Public administration is an interdisciplinary field grounded primarily in law, political science, and management, with additional influences from economics, sociology, and psychology. Its name might suggest that it is first and foremost a branch of management science devoted to public affairs. On that reading, management science would seem the field’s natural foundation. In recent years, however, managerialism has gained ground in public administration, and the field has increasingly come to emphasize management at the expense of its public purpose.
Publicness as the foundation of public administration
The defining concern of public administration lies in the “public” part of its name. That emphasis on the public explains why “publicness” is the foundation of the discipline. If the field were to focus exclusively on management and neglect its public character, it would lose its basis as a distinct discipline and could readily be absorbed into management science.
By keeping publicness at its core, public administration has gradually developed as a field in its own right and built a consensus around its defining principle. Yet publicness itself is difficult to define, leaving the boundaries of the discipline a fundamental question the field must confront.
How, then, can researchers determine whether research in public administration is achieving its aims? Two criteria are particularly important. First, research in this applied discipline should describe and explain how public administration works in practice and offer practitioners useful insights and guidance.
Second, as a social science, public administration should build a body of knowledge that advances understanding in its own field and in related disciplines. On both counts, the risk that managerialism could erode the discipline warrants attention.
Managerialism blurs disciplinary identity
Managerialism gradually made its way into public administration as management science developed. Frederick Winslow Taylor’s The Principles of Scientific Management, published in 1911, laid the foundations for management science as an academic discipline. In the book, Taylor outlined several principles of scientific management, including science, harmony, cooperation, and maximum output. Together, these principles formed his philosophy of management.
The New Public Management (NPM) movement, which emerged in the 1970s, urged governments to learn from business. It sought to help governments “do more with less” by introducing market competition, adopting a customer focus, evaluating performance, and contracting out public services.
Meanwhile, researchers in public administration drew extensively on concepts and theories from business management and examined the similarities and differences between public and private organizations. Many at the time argued that similar management principles applied in both sectors. As a result, numerous management scholars worked across both sectors, and studies of government management appeared in leading management journals.
Yet managing a government is a fundamentally different undertaking from managing a business. The debate between Herbert A. Simon and Dwight Waldo brings that distinction into focus. Simon criticized public administration for relying on theories that often amounted to little more than proverbs and rarely underwent empirical testing. Waldo, by contrast, emphasized the values that inform public administration, arguing that one must first establish “what ought to be” before considering “what is.” Simon’s approach prioritizes measurable and generalizable management techniques, while Waldo’s starts from the premise that public administration is grounded in values of its own.
Reaffirming the centrality of publicness
The importance of publicness becomes clearer when public organizations are compared with their counterparts in the private sector and civil society. Their objectives, sources of authority, and constraints differ fundamentally, limiting the extent to which the same management principles and tools can be applied across all three sectors. Public administration should remain open to ideas from other fields, drawing on general concepts and theories from business management while accounting for what distinguishes public organizations and public officials. Recent reassessments of the New Public Management and renewed interest in traditional public administration illustrate the need for both.
Public administration must resist being cast as a testing ground for business management theories. Taking on the task of testing and promoting those theories would risk making the discipline subordinate to business management. The public and private sectors pursue different values and operate in different environments, so each calls for its own approach to research. Left unchecked, managerialism could pull public administration away from its core concerns and narrow its intellectual horizons. The discipline must remain open to ideas from other fields while reinforcing its defining principles and building a firmer consensus around them. With a stronger foundation of its own and sustained influence beyond its boundaries, public administration can engage with other fields on equal terms and contribute to a productive exchange of knowledge.
Ma Liang is a professor from the School of Government at Peking University.
Editor:Yu Hui
Copyright©2026 CSSN All Rights Reserved