HOME>WHAT'S NEW>PHOTO

Turning APEC consensus into shared action

Source:Chinese Social Sciences Today 2026-11-20

Zheng Yongnian Photo: Wang Zhou/CSST

The 33rd APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting was held in Shenzhen, Guangdong Province, on Nov. 18-19, 2026, marking China’s third time hosting the meeting after Shanghai in 2001 and Beijing in 2014. Under the theme “Building an Asia-Pacific Community to Prosper Together,” this year’s meeting focused on three priority areas: openness, innovation, and cooperation. Ahead of the meeting, CSST spoke with Professor Zheng Yongnian, dean of the School of Public Policy at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen; president of the Institute for International Affairs, Qianhai; and chairman of the Guangzhou Institute of the Greater Bay Area, on APEC’s role in advancing openness, consensus-building, and regional cooperation.

Mutual empowerment 

CSST: What do you see as the principal challenges facing the world today, and why have you consistently used the term “mutual empowerment” to describe the relationship between China and APEC?

Zheng: The world is currently grappling with four simultaneous crises: geopolitical tensions, imbalances in the global economy, conflicts among civilizations, and global governance challenges. Compounding these crises is the enormous uncertainty surrounding AI. Countries must confront these challenges directly and develop effective responses. China, for its part, has put forward the Global Development Initiative, Global Security Initiative, Global Civilization Initiative, and Global Governance Initiative, each offering a Chinese approach to addressing one of the four crises.

AI is at the heart of the Fourth Industrial Revolution now unfolding, but it also brings enormous uncertainty. The many dimensions of this uncertainty can be summed up in three English words beginning with the letter “S.” The first is “Safety,” which concerns both economic and technological risks. The second is “Security,” referring primarily to military security. The third is “Stupidity,” which concerns AI’s impact on human beings themselves.

Moreover, AI capacity is highly concentrated in China and the United States, while more than 150 economies around the world lack the relevant infrastructure. The two countries therefore have a particular responsibility to engage in dialogue and seek at least a basic consensus—otherwise, AI may well bring the world more trouble than benefits. No country can address these interwoven crises and the uncertainties arising from technological change on its own. The way forward ultimately lies in development and cooperation, which is precisely why China’s hosting of APEC in 2026 matters. I see the relationship between China and APEC as one of “mutual empowerment.” For China, this means drawing on our own capabilities to empower APEC.

In turn, APEC also empowers China. In recent years, we have consistently emphasized high-standard and institutional opening up, and APEC offers an opportunity to put institutional opening up to the test. Additional measures introduced during the meeting can, if they prove effective, be retained and built upon.

We “buy globally and sell globally,” and our trade in goods is already highly globalized. Yet international engagement among our people and the global integration of our institutions and mechanisms have not kept pace. To broaden that engagement, Shenzhen has proposed making this “an APEC for everyone in Shenzhen,” rather than an event involving only the government and relevant institutions. APEC’s potential to empower Shenzhen, Guangdong Province, and indeed the entire country thus extends across many spheres, giving it a significance far beyond the hosting of a single major international event.

‘Open-source’ approach 

CSST: You have repeatedly emphasized that “openness is the fundamental prerequisite.” As deglobalization and trade protectionism gain momentum, how can we make openness genuinely accessible?

Zheng: Openness is the fundamental prerequisite for innovation and cooperation. Innovation arises essentially from the movement, adaptation, and integration of various factors of production. Without openness, these factors cannot flow freely, leaving no basis for innovation, much less international cooperation.

At the same time, we must recognize that openness is not a free lunch—it comes with conditions and thresholds. If the threshold is set too high, many countries will be unable to meet it. If it is set too low, openness loses its meaning.

Tariffs offer a particularly clear example of the conditions that shape openness. Across the APEC region, the average tariff rate has fallen from 17% to 5%. Alongside this progress, 2026 marks the 20th anniversary of APEC Leaders’ proposal of the Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific (FTAAP) agenda.

We favor an “open-source” approach to openness. Having achieved development, Western countries pulled away the ladder they had used to climb to the top, requiring other countries to meet numerous conditions before granting them access. China, by contrast, extends the ladder to others, allowing and encouraging them to climb it as well. We can describe this as “open-source modernization,” an approach fundamentally different from the Western model in which others are expected to follow an established example while also complying with imposed conditions.

Distinctive value of consensus 

CSST: Some analysts argue that nonbinding, consensus-based mechanisms such as APEC have become less effective relative to those with more binding obligations. In an international system where these different approaches coexist, where does APEC’s distinctive value lie?

Zheng: APEC is sometimes dismissed as little more than a procedural exercise because it lacks legally binding authority. I take precisely the opposite view. The WTO, the WHO, and even the United Nations all have legally binding rules. Why, then, have they become less effective today?

APEC embodies inclusive multilateralism. Its strength lies precisely in the absence of legally binding obligations—its purpose is to build consensus. Businesses, as the principal actors in trade, globalization, and economic cooperation, are pragmatic and understand the importance of cooperation and compromise. Economic relations need not be a zero-sum game: They can benefit both sides, or indeed all parties involved. APEC draws its resilience from this potential for mutual benefit.

The same principle underlies institutional opening up, which extends openness to rules, management systems, and standards. Good rules should be retained, those that no longer reflect current realities should be revised, and new rules should be developed through open discussion. Such an approach is fully consistent with APEC’s emphasis on consensus and deliberation.

Territorial embeddedness, openness, security 

CSST: You have proposed that the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area should become a “territorially embedded economic platform” and a “world-class bay area.” What exactly do you mean by “territorially embedded,” and what gives the Greater Bay Area the conditions and capacity to realize this vision?

Zheng: Economies that have achieved genuine development are all territorially embedded. Such embeddedness requires continual improvements to the business environment, both to attract a wide range of factors of production and to ensure that they support sustained development within the local economy.

The figures demonstrate the Greater Bay Area’s capacity. Accounting for less than 0.6% of China’s land area and 6% of its population, it generates approximately one-ninth of the country’s total economic output. Its per capita GDP of around $23,000 places it above what is commonly regarded in China as the threshold for a moderately developed economy and broadly in line with high-income economy levels. Since 2023, its total economic output has exceeded that of both the New York and San Francisco Bay Areas, placing it alongside Tokyo Bay in the top tier of the world’s bay-area economies. Its innovative strength is also evident: in the World Intellectual Property Organization’s Global Innovation Index 2025, the Shenzhen-Hong Kong-Guangzhou innovation cluster ranked first globally after five consecutive years in second place.

These strengths make Shenzhen an appropriate choice to host the meeting. The city combines its roles as a manufacturing hub and a center of scientific and technological innovation with the support of the wider Greater Bay Area, including Hong Kong. Hosting the meeting here means doing the right thing, in the right place, at the right time. It also offers an opportunity to expand the Greater Bay Area’s role as a platform, promote the global expansion of Chinese companies, and strengthen supply-chain resilience.

Territorial embeddedness and APEC-driven openness rest on the same approach to managing the relationship between openness and security. Both require us to pursue openness while safeguarding security—including economic security—and to maintain balanced development, in keeping with an ancient Chinese philosophical tradition.

Greater Bay Area’s institutional contribution 

CSST: As the Fourth Industrial Revolution unfolds and new quality productive forces develop, how do you assess China’s position in this round of global competition?

Zheng: China’s greatest comparative advantage is its productive capacity. Its strengths lie in the real economy and manufacturing, while its degree of financialization remains relatively low. China therefore has particular reason to complement its strengths in the real economy with rules and regulatory frameworks that prevent capital from circulating without contributing to productive activity.

Two priorities follow from this. First, we must continue to enhance high-quality productive capacity and pursue technological progress. Second, and more importantly, we must establish rules and regulatory frameworks that prevent a race to the bottom and destructive competition. Europe has little productive capacity, yet it has consistently invested effort in rulemaking and regulation. China has productive capacity, but risks finding itself at a disadvantage unless it also develops the rules and regulatory frameworks to match.

Putting these two priorities into practice in the Greater Bay Area begins with a fundamental question: What rules and standards should govern the region? The answer must be worked out across a wide range of fields, including biomedicine and AI, each with its own requirements. Only with appropriate rules and regulatory frameworks in place can openness become a practical reality.

For these reasons, I believe that rules and regulatory frameworks, together with a common market, could be the most valuable institutional legacy of this year’s APEC meeting for the Asia-Pacific region and the world. Through a commitment to rules, market principles, and openness, China can turn its strength in productive capacity into a regional public good shared by all. As the world confronts interwoven crises, we must both open our doors to others and reach out internationally to play an active part in advancing global cooperation.

Editor:Yu Hui

Copyright©2023 CSSN All Rights Reserved

Copyright©2026 CSSN All Rights Reserved

京ICP备11013869号